Chappaqua sold far fewer single-family homes in 2026 than it did in 2025, and its median price still went up. Houlihan Lawrence's third-quarter report counts 47 single-family sales in the Chappaqua school district from July through September 2026, compared with 68 in the same quarter of 2025. That is a 31 percent decline. Year to date through September, the count was 98 sales against 148. Over the same nine months the median sale price rose 8 percent, from $1,505,750 to $1,627,500.
The drop in Chappaqua sales reads as a shortage of sellers. Buyers who stop showing up leave behind unsold homes and softer prices, and Chappaqua has neither. The likelier reading is that fewer owners put their homes on the market, and the buyers who were looking competed for a smaller pool. For someone comparing Chappaqua with nearby towns, that changes how to plan a search here.
Ten years of closings put 2026 in familiar territory
A one-year comparison makes 2026 look like a slump. A ten-year view looks different. Houlihan Lawrence's Chappaqua single-family history, built on OneKey MLS data, counts 192 sales in 2017, 180 in 2018 and 181 in 2019. Sales then jumped to 304 in 2020 and 278 in 2021, eased to 212 in 2022, and fell to 150 in 2023 and 160 in 2024 before climbing to 188 in 2025.
The same report counts 124 sales for 2026 through October 31. Stretched across twelve months at the same pace, that comes to roughly 149 sales. That is almost exactly the 2023 total and just below 2024. Against that history, 2025 looks like the busy year, and 2026 looks like a return to the turnover Chappaqua has had since the post-2020 wave ended.
The medians over those same years tell the other half of the story. The Chappaqua median was $857,000 in 2017. It reached $1.14 million in 2021, reached $1,502,500 in 2024, held at $1,501,750 in 2025, and stands at $1,630,000 for 2026 through October. The lean years of 2023 and 2024 were not cheap years. In 2024, with only 160 sales, the median rose about 15 percent. Chappaqua has a pattern of low sales counts lining up with rising prices, and 2026 fits it.
The prices and the pace point to fewer sellers
The October report shows how the market behaved once fall began. In October 2026, Houlihan Lawrence recorded 9 single-family closings in Chappaqua, down 47.1 percent from October 2025. Those homes sold in an average of 38 days, about 11.6 percent faster than a year earlier, and they closed at an average of about 104.9 percent of original list price. A market where homes sell faster than last year and above their asking prices is not short of buyers.
Months of inventory doubled, from 0.9 in October 2025 to 1.80 in October 2026. The number of homes for sale at the end of the month stayed flat at 16. Months of inventory divides the homes for sale by the recent pace of sales. Here the pace dropped while the stock did not grow, so the ratio rose without a single extra listing. Even at 1.80, Chappaqua sits below the 2.5 months of supply OneKey MLS reported for all of Westchester County in the third quarter of 2026.
The October median of $1,820,000 is up 30.8 percent from October 2025. With only nine closings behind it, that figure mostly reflects which nine houses happened to close. The steadier signal is the quarterly median, up 6 percent in the third quarter, and the year-to-date median, up 8 percent.
Next door, the count moved the other way
If something regional were pulling demand down, every Northern Westchester district would show it. They do not. Across Northern Westchester, third-quarter 2026 sales rose 1 percent from the third quarter of 2025, and the median sale price rose 5 percent. Underneath that flat total, the school districts Houlihan Lawrence uses as reporting areas moved in very different directions.
| District, Houlihan Lawrence reporting area | Q3 2026 sales | Q3 2025 sales | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bedford | 99 | 71 | +39% |
| Somers | 58 | 45 | +29% |
| Katonah-Lewisboro | 60 | 65 | -8% |
| Byram Hills | 29 | 40 | -28% |
| Chappaqua | 47 | 68 | -31% |
Bedford's third-quarter count jumped by more than a third while Chappaqua's fell by nearly a third. Byram Hills lost sales at almost the same rate as Chappaqua, and its third-quarter median still climbed 11 percent to $2,062,125. Chappaqua and Byram Hills are the two districts in this table where sales fell steeply while prices kept rising, the pattern of a market with steady demand and fewer owners selling.
The regional snapshot at the end of September matches that reading. Northern Westchester had 182 active listings on September 30, 2026, against 196 a year earlier, and 116 pending sales against 151. Fewer homes on the market led to fewer contracts. A large surplus of homes sitting unsold would mean something else, and the area does not have one.
What a thin year means if you are comparing towns
For a buyer weighing Chappaqua against Bedford or Armonk, the useful takeaway concerns selection, more than price. A year when Chappaqua turns over about 150 single-family homes gives you far fewer chances to find the right one than a year like 2020, when it turned over 304. Each month brings a handful of new options, and in October 2026 those homes went under contract and closed above their original asking prices on average. A buyer who waits for a deep inventory to choose from will mostly wait.
The calendar tightens that further. Across Westchester County, single-family new listings fell from 1,400 in the third quarter of 2025 to 823 in the fourth quarter, and months of supply dropped to 1.5. That is a countywide pattern, not a Chappaqua figure. Still, a town that starts the season with only 16 homes for sale has little room to absorb a seasonal drop in listings. Buyers looking in Chappaqua between Thanksgiving and the new year should expect very few choices. The ones who are ready when a fitting house appears, with financing lined up and a clear sense of what they would pay, will be in the strongest position.
Comparing towns also means comparing different kinds of scarcity. Bedford's rise in third-quarter sales means more houses changed hands there this year, which gives a buyer more to look at. Chappaqua's tight supply works in favor of anyone who already owns there. For a commuter focused on the Harlem Line, our guide to Chappaqua for NYC commuters covers the trade-offs between train access and lot size that shape which of those few listings fit.
Owners thinking about selling in 2027 are reading the same numbers from the other side. With a 2026 year-to-date median of $1,630,000 and October homes closing at about 104.9 percent of original list on average, the present market rewards a well-prepared house that comes on when few others are available. A home valuation based on recent Chappaqua closings is the place to start.
A few questions buyers ask about these numbers
Did Chappaqua's prices fall along with its sales? No. Houlihan Lawrence reports the Chappaqua year-to-date median through September 2026 at $1,627,500, up 8 percent from the same period in 2025.
Is 2026 an unusually slow year for Chappaqua? Measured against the past decade, it is close to normal. At its pace through October, 2026 is on track for about 149 sales, close to the 150 in 2023 and the 160 in 2024.
Does the higher months-of-inventory figure mean buyers have more leverage? The October increase to 1.80 months came from fewer sales. The number of homes for sale stayed at 16, unchanged from a year earlier.
In a year when Chappaqua lists so few homes, timing and preparation decide most outcomes, for buyers watching for the right house and for owners deciding when to sell. If you are weighing a Chappaqua purchase or sale and want to talk through how these 2026 numbers apply to the street or price range you have in mind, reach out to Harriet Libov. Let's Connect.